Builders pulled 56 residential building permits in Tontitown in the first half of 2026, up from 21 in the second half of 2025. The average value of those permits was $388,585, according to the University of Arkansas Center for Business and Economic Research's Skyline Report for the first half of 2026. In the same report, Bentonville's average was $386,050 and Springdale's was $248,794. If you're comparing new homes along U.S. 412 and expecting Tontitown to be a cheaper version of Springdale, the permit data puts it in a higher bracket.
Once you know the price range, a second comparison matters. Within Tontitown, newer subdivisions differ in ways a floor plan won't show: how each one is connected to sewer, who maintains that connection, and how quickly the city's water and sewer projects can open more lots near Barrington Road.
Permit values put Tontitown with Bentonville
The Skyline figures are permit valuations, not sale prices. They're still useful for comparing towns, because every city in the report is measured the same way. For January through June 2026, Fayetteville came in at $370,712, Elm Springs at $441,860, and Cave Springs at $633,769. Tontitown's $388,585 sits in the middle of that group, a few thousand dollars from Bentonville. It also dipped from $410,636 in the second half of 2025, even as the number of permits more than doubled.
Lot prices tell the same story. In December 2025, Talk Business & Politics reported that the 73 lots in Bariloche's second phase, on 19.81 acres near Klenc Road, sold for $98,000 each. The same day they resold for $118,000 each under a two-year option for Schuber Mitchell Homes. A $118,000 lot leaves little room for an entry-level price once the house is built.
For the wider market, the Northwest Arkansas Board of REALTORS reported a Washington County average sale price of $418,976 for October 2026, with 298 closed sales and an average of 52 days on market. Those are countywide figures, so they show the market Tontitown's builders are pricing against.
One more dated cost belongs in the comparison. Tontitown's city code lists water and wastewater impact fees of $4,640 and $3,488 for a 5/8-by-3/4-inch meter, under Ordinance 2026-02-1259, passed Feb. 17, 2026. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm the amounts for any specific property with the city and your own advisers.
Four subdivisions, four arrangements underground
Bariloche. Schuber Mitchell Homes lists Bariloche from $349,999, with plans from 1,726 to 3,093 square feet. At the time of writing, its available homes were listed between $384,973 and $399,790. It has the lowest starting price of the communities here. Builder prices change often, so treat any number on a sales page as a snapshot.
Renley Rae. D.R. Horton lists Renley Rae as now selling, with homes from $465,000 and plans from 2,252 to 2,639 square feet. The builder files it under Springdale, but Phase II went before Tontitown's planning staff in June 2026. That staff report describes 50 lots at Klenc Road and Morsani Avenue, with an 8-inch water main and an onsite 12-inch sewer main. It's worth confirming which city's services a Renley Rae address uses before you compare utility costs.
Amalfi. Amalfi is the largest plat in this group: 112 single-family lots, two detention lots and one commercial lot on 38.68 acres near Barrington and Fletcher. Its final plat came before the city in August 2026. It's the only plat in this group with a commercial lot in it, so ask the builder what's planned for that lot before you choose a homesite.
Sloan Crest. Sloan Crest is the smallest: 28 buildable lots and one detention lot on 13.407 acres at 859 S. Barrington Road, about 0.8 miles south of Highway 412. Its sewer is a STEP system with a 2-inch force main. The staff report says the POA or homebuilder is responsible for installing and maintaining it. Its final plat was on the city's Oct. 27 meeting agenda.
Willow Trace shows how much sewer can shape a project. The January 2025 staff report describes 64 lots on about 20 acres near Dowell Road and Kelly Avenue. The project had stalled earlier over sanitary sewer challenges and came back with a redesigned layout that uses a lift station to pump into the South Pointe sewer system. Staff recommended conditional approval.
All four are new construction, and Bariloche and Renley Rae are about $115,000 apart at their starting prices. Even so, the sewer arrangement can be the bigger difference for an owner over the years, because it decides what equipment sits on the lot and who services it.
What a STEP system adds to your list of questions
In a STEP system, each home has its own septic tank and pump. Solids stay in the tank, and the pump sends the liquid into a pressurized sewer main. The pump runs on electricity, according to Springdale Water Utilities. The utility says a typical family of three generally needs its tank pumped every 11 to 12 years, and more often if the wrong things go down the drain.
Who maintains the system depends on the subdivision. In Springdale's former Bethel Heights pressure-sewer area, the utility stopped maintaining customer STEP systems effective Jan. 1, 2023, and homeowners there now own and maintain the tank, pump and controls. Sloan Crest's plat assigns that work to the POA or homebuilder. Two homes a few miles apart can have the same equipment and different people responsible for it. Before you write an offer on a STEP home in Tontitown, get answers to four questions in writing: who owns the tank and pump, who services them, how the POA pays for that service, and what happens when the builder hands the POA over to homeowners.
How fast new lots can open depends on Barrington Road
Tontitown's monthly water and sewer reports show where the next round of building depends on infrastructure. The August 2026 report describes the Barrington Sewer Lift Station as "quickly approaching its maximum pumping capacity." It proposes the Brush Creek Sewer Interceptor, about 6,000 feet of 18-inch sewer main running to Springdale Water Utilities' line at Javello Road, which would allow the lift station to be retired. The September report says the service-area agreement with Springdale Water Utilities was signed and the agreement with Elm Springs was still in process. In October, the project was waiting on easement documents.
Water storage has already caught up. The city's old 0.5-million-gallon elevated tank held less than 12 hours of storage at current demand. The new 1-million-gallon tank in eastern Tontitown was in service by September, and its final walkthrough was held Oct. 14.
The sewer system's longer-term plan is still being written. The October report lists CK Civil's Wastewater Master Plan with a completion window of December 2026. That plan identifies system deficiencies and future projects. A buyer looking at Tontitown in early 2027 will have a much clearer picture of which areas the city plans to serve next.
Two more items affect the west and north sides of town. The city is adding water service territory along Highway 412 west toward Siloam Springs, a step that still needs a preliminary engineering report submitted to the Arkansas Natural Resources Commission. On Highway 112, the city's September and October reports note that ARDOT cancelled the January 2027 bid date for the work that would move several miles of Tontitown's water and sewer lines out of the widening's path. The city's reports list 2027 as the start year for that relocation work, so road and utility crews along Highway 112 are part of the outlook for homes near that corridor.
The rest of the region adds context. Across Northwest Arkansas in the first half of 2026, the number of finished homes still waiting for buyers fell 6.6 percent to 700, while empty lots in active subdivisions rose to 4,920. Region-wide, there's plenty of platted ground and fewer finished homes ready for a move-in. In Tontitown, how quickly platted ground becomes finished homes depends partly on the projects above.
A few quick answers
Is new construction in Tontitown cheaper than in Springdale? Not by permit value. Springdale averaged $248,794 per permit in the first half of 2026, and Tontitown averaged $388,585. The closest comparison in that report is Bentonville.
Does every new Tontitown home have a STEP tank? No. Sloan Crest's plat uses STEP, Renley Rae Phase II's staff report describes an onsite sewer main, and Willow Trace was redesigned around a lift station. Ask about each subdivision, and each phase.
How does the new road network fit in? Springdale's new interstate route to XNA makes the trip from northwest Springdale and Tontitown shorter, as covered in our look at the new road to XNA. Tontitown's own growth has been concentrated along Barrington Road, as covered in this piece on the town's second stoplight.
If you're comparing Bariloche, Renley Rae, Amalfi or Sloan Crest, I'm glad to pull the plat, POA documents and sewer details for the homes on your list so you know what's under the lot before you write an offer. You can see how I work with buyers or start with my Tontitown community page, then reach out to Amanda Gainey. Let's work together.